The Broken Circle Breakdown [Film]

As this year’s Belgian offering to the Oscars, The Broken Circle Breakdown is truly a moving piece of work at points.

Its expert direction neatly sidesteps the possibility of melodrama – Didier and Elise meet and fall in love, to eventually lose their young daughter to cancer – with ease. Certainly the film runs the gamut of emotions, yet each is depicted with equal clarity, presented by two wonderful central performances that bring life and light to the script’s believable characterisation.

A picture from Broken Circle Breakdown


Doubling as a love letter to bluegrass, its musical interludes inject a charm that further rounds out proceedings, adding a further voice to the story.

Really, The Broken Circle Breakdown could and should have been close to faultless, if not for an (eventual) anti-Bush subplot of sorts that adds little. Its raison d’être is to illustrate a loss that extends further than that of the child and the impending doom of the relationship.

However, its culmination in a lengthy rant threatens to derail the film; its inclusion feels unnatural and uncomfortable for not quite marrying with the character in question.A picture from Broken Circle Breakdown


Thankfully, the groundwork is sufficiently strong for this to be a temporary blip in what is overall an almost completely immersive experience.

In lesser hands, the non-linear format could have dampened this involvement, taking the viewer out of the moment, yet the screenplay – based upon co-star Johan Heldenbergh’s stage production – metes out its contrasting dramas with an expertise that belies the relative inexperience of its authors in feature-writing.

Complementing this is a seamless edit that at no point jars, effectively melding the story’s past joy and present sorrow to emphasise its tragic outcome.

Released today on DVD

Naila Scargill
About Naila Scargill 269 Articles
Naila Scargill is the publisher and editor of horror journal Exquisite Terror. Holding a broad editorial background, she has worked with an eclectic variety of content, ranging from film and the counterculture, to political news and finance.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.